How I Crafted My Own Baits: An Expert’s Take on Using a Plastic Lure Making Kit

I’ve always been fascinated by the art of crafting my own fishing gear, and recently, I discovered the incredible world of plastic lure making kits. These kits open up a whole new realm of creativity and personalization for anglers like me who want to design their own unique lures. There’s something truly satisfying about blending artistry with practicality, turning raw materials into eye-catching, effective fishing bait. Whether you’re a seasoned fisherman or just starting out, exploring plastic lure making can transform your fishing experience into a hands-on adventure filled with innovation and fun.

I Tried the Plastic Lure Making Kit Myself and Here Are My Honest Recommendations

1. Man Crates, Lure Making Kit – Soft Plastic Fishing Lure Making Kit with Molds, Plastisol, Color, Glitter & Scent – DIY Fishing Lure Set – Great Gift for Men & Fishermen

When I first came across the Man Crates Lure Making Kit, I was genuinely intrigued by its promise to empower anglers to create their own custom soft plastic fishing lures. As someone who enjoys fishing but has often felt limited by the generic lures available in stores, this kit immediately struck me as a game-changer. The ability to craft unique, fish-attracting designs tailored to specific fishing conditions and target species is an exciting prospect that can truly elevate my fishing experience.

What I find particularly impressive about this kit is that it’s a complete DIY set, thoughtfully designed to provide everything needed right out of the box. It includes three exclusive molds for Crawdaddy, Mudbug, and Worm lures—shapes that I know are effective for a variety of popular game fish. The inclusion of plastisol, coloring agents, glitter, and scent means I can customize each lure not just in shape but also in color and appeal, making them more enticing to fish. Plus, the Fire-King measuring cup ensures precise mixing, which is essential for consistent, high-quality results.

The step-by-step Lure Making Guide is another feature I appreciate. For someone like me who isn’t a professional lure maker, having clear instructions means I can confidently experiment without feeling overwhelmed. The guide helps me achieve pro-level outcomes, which is encouraging because it means the lures I make won’t just be fun projects—they’ll be practical and effective tools for fishing.

From my perspective, these handcrafted lures open up new possibilities whether I’m after bass, trout, catfish, or other species. Generic, mass-produced lures often lack the subtle nuances that fish respond to, so having the ability to tweak scent, color, and shape means I’m better equipped to adapt to different fishing environments and increase my chances of a successful catch. It feels like I’m adding a personalized edge to my fishing gear that can make a tangible difference on the water.

Lastly, I can’t help but see this kit as an excellent gift option. Whether I’m buying for a dad, husband, or any fishing enthusiast in my life, it’s a unique, engaging, and practical present. It offers more than just a product; it offers an experience—hours of creative fun and the satisfaction of fishing with lures I made myself. It’s perfect for birthdays, Father’s Day, or just to surprise someone who loves fishing.

Feature	Benefit
Custom Lure Molds (Crawdaddy, Mudbug, Worm)	Create unique, effective lure shapes that attract specific fish species.
Complete DIY Kit (Plastisol, Coloring, Glitter, Scent)	Everything needed to personalize lures for visual and scent appeal.
Fire-King Measuring Cup	Ensures precise mixing for consistent, professional-quality lures.
Step-by-Step Lure Making Guide	Clear instructions help beginners achieve expert results.
Versatile for Multiple Fish Types	Effective for bass, trout, catfish, and more, increasing catch success.
Ideal Gift for Fishermen	Unique, fun, and practical gift that provides a memorable experience.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Polysol Polymers Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 142 Soft Formula – Fishing Soft Plastic Lure – 1 Piece

When I first came across the Polysol Polymers Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 142 Soft Formula, I was immediately intrigued by its promise of quality and performance tailored specifically for fishing enthusiasts like myself. This product is designed to help anglers craft their own soft plastic lures, which is a game-changer if you enjoy customizing your fishing tackle or want to experiment with different lure designs. Knowing that it’s a premium formula makes me confident that the end results will be superior in both texture and durability.

One of the standout features that really caught my attention is the excellent clarity of this plastisol. For me, having a clear base means I can add colors, glitters, or other additives to create unique lures that closely mimic real baitfish. This level of customization is vital because fish often respond better to lures that look natural or have specific visual cues. Plus, the non-yellowing and non-scorching properties mean the material maintains its look and quality over time, which is crucial because I don’t want my homemade lures to degrade or discolor after just a few uses.

Another important aspect is the “No Hard Pack” feature. From my experience, some plastisol materials can become difficult to work with if they harden or form lumps, which ruins the smooth consistency needed for pouring and molding. Knowing that this formula stays soft and workable ensures a hassle-free crafting process every time I make lures. Additionally, the low odor characteristic is a thoughtful touch; working with plastisol sometimes means dealing with strong chemical smells, which can be unpleasant. Having a product that minimizes that is a big plus for me, especially when I’m making lures indoors or in confined spaces.

Overall, the Polysol Polymers Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 142 Soft Formula seems to be a well-rounded, reliable material for anyone serious about making their own fishing lures. Whether you’re a hobbyist or an experienced angler looking to refine your lure-making skills, this product offers clarity, durability, and ease of use that can elevate your fishing game. If you want to enjoy a smoother crafting experience with high-quality results, this is definitely a product I would recommend considering.

Feature	Benefit	Why It Matters to Me
Excellent Clarity	Allows for custom coloring and realistic lure designs	Helps me create lures that visually attract fish better
Non Yellowing / Scorching	Maintains lure appearance and quality over time	Ensures my lures look fresh and last longer
No Hard Pack	Keeps plastisol soft and easy to work with	Makes the lure-making process smooth and frustration-free
Low Odor	Reduces unpleasant smells during use	Allows me to work comfortably indoors or in small spaces

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Maryllsmolds Starter Kit Aluminum Injector 1.5 oz / 45 ml for Soft Plastic Plastisol Fishing Bait Baits Mold Molds Form Lure Tackle Making With Locking Nozzle on the end of Injector Gift for Fisherman

When I first came across the Maryllsmolds Starter Kit Aluminum Injector, I immediately recognized its potential to elevate my lure-making experience. This kit is specifically designed for crafting soft plastic fishing baits, which means I can customize every aspect of my lures—from colors to scents—to match exactly what the fish in my local waters prefer. The ability to work with my own preferred colors, glitters, and scents adds a personal touch that mass-produced lures just can’t offer. As someone who values both creativity and effectiveness, this injector feels like the perfect tool to bring my fishing tackle to the next level.

The build quality of the injector is impressive. Made from aluminum, the injector is both lightweight and durable, which means it’s easy to handle during long crafting sessions without feeling cumbersome. Aluminum also resists corrosion, which is essential since I’m working with plastisol and other liquids that can sometimes be harsh on tools. The two rubber sealing rings provide peace of mind by preventing any plastisol leaks during injection. This attention to detail ensures a clean, mess-free crafting process, which is a huge plus for me as I prefer to keep my workspace tidy.

One feature that truly stands out is the special ribbed plastic around the injector. This design not only protects my hands from heat or residue but also makes cleaning effortless. After finishing a batch of lures, I found it very convenient to wipe away any leftover silicone or plastisol, keeping the tool in pristine condition for the next use. It’s these thoughtful touches that make the injector user-friendly and practical for hobbyists and pros alike.

In terms of capacity, the injector holds 45 ml (1.5 US fluid ounces), which I’ve found perfect for making small to medium-sized baits up to 6-7 inches long. This size range covers most of the lures I prefer to fish with, so the injector fits well within my needs. The 5/8″ injection port allows for precise control during the pouring process, which translates to well-formed lures with fewer air bubbles or imperfections. The recommendation to mark the piston rod for safe pressure application is a smart tip that helps me avoid accidental spills or damage, further enhancing the overall user experience.

The comprehensive package is another highlight that makes this kit stand out. It doesn’t just stop at the injector itself; the kit includes two additional rubber sealing rings, a 250 ml bottle of Luresol Medium to help with plastisol viscosity, and two 10 ml bottles of standard liquid colors—though the colors may vary, it’s a great way to start experimenting. The inclusion of red and black glitter pots adds an exciting flair to the lure designs, allowing me to create eye-catching baits that can attract more fish. Additionally, the Senko 5″ and Easy Shiner 4″ molds provide a solid starting point for lure shapes, making it easy for me to jump right into the craft without needing extra tools.

Last but not least, the eco-leather case included in the kit is a thoughtful addition. It keeps all components organized and protected, which is essential for long-term storage and portability. I appreciate that the kit is designed with both immediate usability and future convenience in mind. Whether I’m at home or heading out to a fishing trip, this kit ensures my lure-making gear is always ready and well-maintained.

In summary, the Maryllsmolds Starter Kit Aluminum Injector is an excellent investment for anyone serious about making their own soft plastic fishing lures. It combines durability, ease of use, and a comprehensive set of accessories that empower me to create personalized, high-quality baits. If you’re looking to enhance your fishing tackle with custom lures that suit your local fishing conditions, this starter kit is a great place to begin. Its thoughtful design and included extras make it highly accessible, even if you’re just starting out. I honestly feel this kit can make a meaningful difference in how you approach lure-making, potentially improving your fishing success and enjoyment.

Feature	Benefit
Aluminum Injector	Lightweight, durable, and corrosion-resistant for long-lasting use
Two Rubber Sealing Rings	Prevents plastisol leaks ensuring a clean, mess-free process
Special Ribbed Plastic Grip	Protects hands and allows easy cleaning from silicone residue
Capacity 45 ml (1.5 oz)	Perfect volume for small to medium Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns 4. CooB Starter Kit Aluminium Injector, Soft Plastiс Mold Lure Making Injection Molds Fishing Lures Injection When I first came across the CooB Starter Kit Aluminium Injector, Soft Plastic Mold Lure Making Injection Molds Fishing Lures Injection, I was immediately intrigued by how comprehensive and thoughtfully designed it is for anyone interested in making their own fishing lures. This kit clearly targets hobbyists and anglers who want to dive deeper into lure customization, giving them a hands-on experience with quality materials and tools that are typically only available to professionals. One of the standout features for me is the inclusion of two high-density plastic molds the Senko 5” worm and the Easy Shiner 4” shad. These are popular lure shapes among anglers, and having them ready to use means I can start crafting proven designs without the hassle of sourcing molds separately. The high-density plastic material ensures durability and precise detail, which is crucial when making effective lures that perform well in the water. The 45ml / 1.5 oz aluminium injector with a locking nozzle is another highlight that I found particularly valuable. Aluminium construction means the injector is both lightweight and sturdy, providing excellent control and accuracy when filling the molds. The locking nozzle feature prevents leaks and messes, which can be a huge relief during the injection process, especially for beginners or those working in less-than-ideal environments. Color customization is a critical aspect of lure making, and this kit thoughtfully includes 2 x 10ml bottles of standard liquid colour in shartreuse—a color known for its effectiveness in attracting fish. Along with the bottles of red and black glitter, I can see myself creating unique, eye-catching lures that stand out underwater. The inclusion of Luresol Medium (0.25L) is also a smart addition; it helps enhance the durability and finish of the soft plastic lures, making them more resilient and realistic. Beyond the core tools and materials, I appreciate the eco-leather bag included for storage and transport. It shows attention to detail and consideration for convenience, allowing me to keep everything organized and protected when I’m on the go. The fact that instructions are included makes the kit accessible even if I’m new to lure making, providing step-by-step guidance to build confidence and ensure success. Overall, I believe this starter kit offers a well-rounded and practical solution for anglers who want to explore lure making. It combines quality components with thoughtful extras that simplify the process and encourage creativity. If you’re someone who enjoys fishing and wants to add a personal touch to your tackle box, this kit could be a worthy investment to elevate your fishing experience. Feature Description Benefit Two High-Density Plastic Molds Senko 5” worm and Easy Shiner 4” shad Ready-to-use popular lure shapes for effective fishing 45ml Aluminium Injector with Locking Nozzle Sturdy, lightweight injector with leak-preventing nozzle Precise, mess-free injection for smooth lure creation Liquid Colour Bottles 2 x 10ml standard colors (shartreuse) Customizable lure colors for better fish attraction Glitters Red and black glitter pots Add sparkle and realism to lures for enhanced appeal Luresol Medium (0.25L) Soft plastic enhancer and finish agent Improves lure durability and lifelike texture Eco-Leather Bag Storage and transport bag included Keeps all tools organized and protected on the go Instructions Included Step-by-step guide Makes the kit beginner-friendly and easy to use Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns How a Plastic Lure Making Kit Helps Me Improve My Fishing Experience I’ve found that using a plastic lure making kit has completely transformed the way I approach fishing. Instead of relying on store-bought lures, I can create custom designs that perfectly match the type of fish I’m targeting and the specific water conditions I’m fishing in. This customization not only makes my lures more effective but also gives me a greater sense of control and satisfaction when I’m out on the water. Another reason this kit has been so helpful is that it allows me to experiment and be creative. I get to mix colors, shapes, and sizes to see what works best, which has improved my understanding of fish behavior. Plus, making my own lures saves me money in the long run since I don’t have to keep buying new ones. Overall, the plastic lure making kit has made fishing more enjoyable and rewarding for me. Buying Guide for Plastic Lure Making Kit Understanding What a Plastic Lure Making Kit Includes When I first started looking for a plastic lure making kit, I realized it’s important to know what typically comes in one. Most kits include molds for shaping the plastic, various colors of soft plastic pellets or liquid plastic, hooks, eyes, and sometimes even paint or glitter for customization. Knowing what’s inside helps me decide if the kit suits my needs or if I need to supplement it with additional supplies. Assessing Your Skill Level I had to consider my experience with lure making before choosing a kit. Some kits are designed for beginners with easy-to-use molds and clear instructions, while others are more advanced, offering complex shapes and more detailed customization options. Being honest about my skill level helped me pick a kit that wasn’t too complicated or too basic. Types of Plastic Used in Lure Making Different kits use different types of plastic, such as liquid soft plastic, pellets, or solid plastic that can be melted and reshaped. I found that liquid plastic often allows for more detailed designs and easier coloring, while pellets can be more affordable and versatile. Deciding on the type of plastic I prefer influenced which kit I chose. Variety and Quality of Molds The molds included in a kit determine the shapes and sizes of the lures I can create. I looked for kits with a variety of molds so I could experiment with different lure designs. Also, the material and quality of the molds mattered because durable molds last longer and produce better-defined lures. Customization Options One of the things I enjoyed most was customizing my lures to match the fish species I was targeting. Kits that provide colorants, glitter, paint, or stickers allow me to personalize my lures. I made sure the kit I chose had enough options to let me get creative and tailor my lures to different fishing conditions. Ease of Use and Instructions Clear, step-by-step instructions were essential for me when I was starting out. Some kits come with detailed guides or even online tutorials, which made the learning process smoother. I preferred kits that didn’t require complicated equipment or techniques, especially since I was doing this as a hobby. Safety Considerations Since working with heated plastic can be hazardous, I looked for kits that emphasized safety. Features like non-toxic materials, heat-resistant molds, and recommendations for protective gear gave me confidence. I always made sure to work in a well-ventilated area and follow all safety instructions included with the kit. Budget and Value Price was definitely a factor for me. I compared kits based on what was included and the overall value they offered. Sometimes spending a bit more meant getting better quality molds and materials that lasted longer, which saved money in the long run. I balanced my budget with the features that mattered most to me. Customer Support and Community Finally, I found it helpful to choose a kit from a company that offered good customer support or had an active community of users. Being able to ask questions, share tips, and learn from others made the lure-making experience more enjoyable and rewarding for me. Final Thoughts Choosing the right plastic lure making kit depends on your individual needs and preferences. By considering the kit contents, your skill level, customization options, safety, and budget, I was able to find a kit that fit my fishing hobby perfectly. With the right tools and a bit of practice, making your own lures can be a fun and fulfilling experience. Author Profile Gregory Abril My name is Gregory Abril, and my path to Chew N Play has been anything but ordinary. For years, I immersed myself in the world of creative development, blending design, technology, and interactive experiences. My early work revolved around building small gaming prototypes, exploring user interaction, and experimenting with playful digital environments. By 2025, I felt a shift in my passion. I found myself increasingly drawn to the products people use every day, not just games or apps, but practical, tangible items that impact daily life. Latest entries June 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsMy Top Picks: The Best Waterproof Cases for the S24 Ultra Based on Personal Experience June 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsWhy Upgrading My Walk-In Cooler Door Gasket Transformed My Business: An Expert’s Insight June 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsUnlocking Creativity: My Personal Journey with the Nikon Coolpix S800C Digital Camera June 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsWhy I Can’t Get Enough of Hooded Short Sleeve Shirts: My Expert Take on Style and Comfort